Ask the Expert: Concerns about canola oil

The expert: Dr. Guy Crosby

I’m confused about whether canola oil is healthy. I know that it’s a polyunsaturated fat, which I’m told is good, but then I also hear that I should stay away from it.

Some of the claims:

• Most canola is chemically extracted using a solvent called hexane, and heat is often applied which can affect the stability of the oil’s molecules, turn it rancid, destroy the omega-3s in it, and can even create trans fats.
• “Cold-pressed” canola oil exists but is very expensive and hard to find.

Should I avoid canola oil?And what are the best fats in general for cooking?

• The top four vegetable oils consumed in the United States are soybean, canola, palm, and corn oil. These are referred to as refined, bleached, deodorized oils – or RBD for short – because this describes the process by which they are manufactured.
• RBD oils are produced by crushing the plant material, usually seeds, to express the oil, followed by extraction of the crushed material with a low-boiling solvent, most commonly hexane, to obtain the remainder of the oil.
• Canola oil is generally considered a “healthy” oil because it is very low in saturated fat (7%). Like olive oil it is high in monounsaturated fat (63%).
• Canola oil also contains a significant level of polyunsaturated omega-3 (ω-3) fat (9-11%),
• In addition, canola oil contains significant amounts of phytosterols (about 0.9% by weight) that reduce the absorption of cholesterol into the body.

As with many highly processed food products there are concerns about the safety of canola oil.
First is the use of a solvent such as hexane to extract the maximum amount of oil from the seed. Hexane is a very volatile solvent (boiling point 69ºC, or 156ºF) with a very low toxicity (LD50 in rats of 49.0 milliliters per kilogram). Hexane has been used to extract oils from plant material since the 1930s, and “there is no evidence to substantiate any risk or danger to consumer health when foods containing trace residual concentrations of hexane are ingested” (1).

It has been estimated that refined vegetable oils extracted with hexane contain approximately 0.8 milligrams of residual hexane per kilogram of oil (0.8 ppm) (2). It is also estimated that the level of ingestion of hexane from all food sources is less than 2% of the daily intake from all other sources, primarily gasoline fumes. There appears to be very little reason for concern about the trace levels of hexane in canola oil.

Another concern is the report that canola oil might contain trans-fats that have been linked with significant health problems. In fact, canola oil does contain very low levels of trans-fat, as do all oils that have been deodorized. Deodorization is the final step in refining ALL vegetable oils. This process produces the bland taste that consumers want.

As a comparison, the fat of cattle and sheep, as well as the milk obtained from cows, contain about 2-5% of natural trans-fat as a percent of the total fat (3). When canola oil is deodorized it is subjected to temperatures above 200ºC (as high as 235ºC, 455°F) under vacuum for various lengths time to remove volatile components such as free fatty acids and phospholipids. During exposure to these high temperatures a small amount of the unsaturated fatty acids, especially the essential ω-6-linoleic and ω-3–linolenic acid, are transformed into trans-fatty acid isomers. Because of earlier studies showing that even quite low levels of trans isomers of ω-3–linolenic can have adverse effects of blood cholesterol fractions, the processes used for deodorization have been modified to limit the production of these compounds.

Other vegetable oils, and even nut oils, have been found to contain levels of trans-fatty acids that are comparable to the levels in beef fat. The table below summarizes the content of trans-fatty acids found in a number of oils (4). In both canola oil and soybean oil, trans-isomers of linoleic acid have been found to account for 0.2-1.0% of total fatty acids, while trans-isomers of linolenic acid may total as much as 3% (5). Linolenic acid isomerizes with heat about 12-15 times faster than linoleic acid.

Oil                                 Trans Content (%)
Soybean*                     0.4-2.1%
Walnut*                       2.0-3.9%
Sunflower                    1.1%
Canola*                        1.9-3.6%
Olive                             0.5%
PH soybean oil**       43.6-50.2%


*Results of multiple samples of commercial oil
** Partially hydrogenated soybean oils for comparison

A consequence of transforming some of the natural unsaturated fatty acids to trans-fat during the deodorization step is a reduction in the content of beneficial ω-3–fatty acids.

• Heating bleached canola oil at 220°C for ten hours reduces the content of linolenic acid by almost 20% (5). Keep in mind that canola oil sold in the supermarket still contains 9-11% natural ω-3–linolenic acid.

• The same transformation occurs during commercial deep-fat frying operations with canola oil. Thus canola oil used to fry French fries for seven hours per day for seven days at 185°C (365°F) resulted in increasing the total trans-fatty acid content of the oil from 2.4% to 3.3% by weight of total fat (6).

• Of potentially greater concern is the formation of oxidation products of polyunsaturated fatty acids during prolonged commercial deep-fat frying. But this is less of a concern for canola oil than for oils with higher levels of more readily oxidized polyunsaturated fat such corn, soybean, sunflower, and safflower oils.

When considered in the context of other commercial fats, the low trans-fat content of canola oil is no different from other vegetable oils. But one word of caution is appropriate. Bottles of canola, soybean, and corn oil in the supermarket proudly proclaim “Contains zero grams of trans-fat.” Read the fine print that states zero grams of trans-fat per serving, which is only one tablespoon, or about 14 grams of oil. The FDA allows any component that is less than 0.5 grams per serving to be listed as zero grams! Despite this claim, virtually all vegetable oils sold in the supermarket contain small amounts (less than 5%) of trans-fat.

So what other options are there if one wants to avoid RBD oils?

• Virgin and extra virgin olive oils are good choices. There is ample evidence they are healthy alternatives. They are not extracted with solvent and are not deodorized.
• Some consumers that prefer the bland taste of vegetable oils do not like the stronger flavor of olive oil, so they will not cook with it. But a test done at America’s Test Kitchen found that extra virgin olive oil that had been heated at 350°F (177°C) for ten minutes was virtually indistinguishable from heated soybean oil. All the volatile grassy flavors of extra virgin olive oil had been driven off. So food can be sautéed with olive oil and not taste like olive oil.
• Regular olive oil is processed like other RBD oils. To obtain the benefits of no residues of hexane and almost no trans-fat, virgin and extra virgin grades of olive oil must be used. Other cold-pressed oils, such as cold-pressed canola oil provide the same benefits (7).

Given the above information, is commercially process canola oil harmful?

Although care must be taken in handling and processing of canola oil and other vegetable oils, canola oil is a safe and healthy form of fat that will reduce blood LDL cholesterol levels and heart disease risk compared to carbohydrates or saturated fats such as found in beef tallow or butter. Indeed, in a randomized trial that showed one of the most striking reductions in risk of heart disease, canola oil was used as the primary form of fat (8). Whether using cold pressed canola oil provides some small additional benefit is not clear.

(side note from Sarah: I totally disagree with this statement...I think you should avoid canola oil as much as possible since no matter what it is a highly processed oil that you couldn't get without the use of lots of chemicals. Also, consumption of it will likely throw your balance of omega-3/omega-6 fats off in your body. Stick to fats and oils that don't require crazy amounts of processing to get, like cold-pressed olive oil, grass-fed tallow, pasture-raised lard, butter, ghee, and coconut oil)

In general, variety is a good strategy in nutrition, and thus consuming a variety of oils is desirable, for example using extra virgin oil when the special flavor is desired and canola oil or soybean oil for other uses. Both canola and soybean oils provide ω-3 fatty acids that are important to include in an overall diet. Of course, avoiding overheating and burning of oils is important to provide the best taste and to avoid damaging the healthy-promoting fatty acids that they contain.

References


1. Swanson, R. G., Regents Professor, Department of Food Science, Washington State University, Hexane Extraction in Soyfoods Processing, 2009.

2. Health Canada, 2009, Guidance Documents, hc-sc.gc.ca.

3. Health Canada, 2006, Guidance Documents, hc-sc.gc.ca.

4. Azizian, H., and Kramer, J. K. G., A Rapid Method for the Quantification of Fatty Acids in Fats and Oil with Emphasis ontrans Fatty Acids Using Fourier Transform Near Infrared Spectroscopy (FT-NIR), Lipids, 2005; 40:855-867.

5. Hénon, G., Kemény, Zs., Recseg, K., Zwobada, F., and Kovari, K., Deodorization of Vegetable Oils. Part I: Modeling the Geometrical Isomerization of Polyunsaturated Fatty Acids, J Am Oil Chem Soc 1999; 76:73-81.

6. Aladedunye, F. A., and Przybylski, R. Degradation and Nutritional Quality Changes of Oil During Frying, J Am Oil Chem Soc 2009; 86:149-156.

7. Gunstone, F. D., ed., Vegetable Oils in Food Technology: Composition, Properties and Uses, Blackstone Publishing, 2002.

8. de Lorgeril et al. Mediterranean alpha-linolenic acid-rich diet in secondary prevention of coronary heart disease Lancet 1994 Jun 11;343(8911):1454-9.

Original Article: http://www.hsph.harvard.edu/nutritionsource/2015/04/13/ask-the-expert-concerns-about-canola-oil/?utm_source=SilverpopMailing&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=Nutrition%20Source%20-%20May%202015%20(1)&utm_content=